The Short Answer
The question “do politicians beat the market?” has been asked since the landmark 2004 Ziobrowski study found that U.S. senators' stock portfolios outperformed the market by 12% annually. Twenty-two years later, with the STOCK Act forcing public disclosure, the raw material is public. Turning it into one honest performance number is harder than it looks.
GovGreed's database contains 99,546 deduplicated STOCK Act filings from 354 members of Congress across 14 years (2012–2026). We cross-reference every trade against 7 independent intelligence layers — committee assignments, bill timing, campaign contributions, lobbying activity, herd behavior, sector momentum, and technical indicators — to produce a master signal score from 0 to 100.
Overall Congressional Trading Performance
Across all 99,546 trades, the picture is more mundane than the headlines suggest. Many trades are routine portfolio management, spousal diversification, or small-dollar positions that have nothing to do with legislative inside knowledge.
The trades worth a closer look are the ones where the context stacks up — a committee member buys a stock in a company their committee oversees, around the time related legislation moves, while their campaign contributors include the same industry. GovGreed's signal engine surfaces those trades so you can read the record behind them.
Out of 354 members who have filed at least one trade, GovGreed's signal engine scores only 61 politicians. The filter is intentional: only trades with an amount midpoint of $50,000 or more are scored, because small-dollar trades (the $1,001–$15,000 range) are statistically meaningless for detecting insider-style signals. A $5,000 trade in Microsoft is portfolio noise. A $500,000 trade in a defense contractor by a member of the Armed Services Committee is a signal.
Signal Tier Performance Breakdown
GovGreed assigns every qualifying trade a master signal score (0–100) and a corresponding tier. The tier describes how much independent context converges on a trade:
| Tier | Score Range | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| S | 75+ | Rare. Nearly every layer converging on one trade. |
| A+ | 60–74 | Strong convergence across several layers. |
| A | 50–59 | Multiple layers aligning. |
| B | 40–49 | Some context, mostly routine. |
| C | 30–39 | Little context behind the trade. |
| D/F | <30 | No convergence. Routine activity. |
We do backtest the tiers, comparing each scored trade's price 30 days after the trade date with its price at the trade. Tier backtests are small-sample and raw (not excess vs the S&P 500), so we don’t publish a tier win rate. A few dozen trades per tier, measured without subtracting the market's own move, is not a result we are willing to put on a marketing page.
Congress vs. the S&P 500
The most common benchmark question: do congressional trades beat a simple buy-and-hold of the S&P 500? The answer depends entirely on which trades you're measuring.
A fair test has to subtract what the S&P 500 did over the same window. A trade that returns +8% during a month when the S&P also returns +8% has earned nothing special. It also needs enough trades that a handful of big winners can't carry the average, and it has to treat a sale as a bet that the stock falls.
Our current tier backtest doesn't clear those bars yet. Tier backtests are small-sample and raw (not excess vs the S&P 500), so we don’t publish a tier win rate. Until it does, the honest answer to “does Congress beat the S&P 500?” is: some members have striking individual trades, and the timing record around those trades is public and worth reading. See it member by member on the Congress leaderboard.
Committee Members vs. Non-Committee
One of the most powerful predictors of congressional trading performance is whether the politician sits on a committee with oversight jurisdiction over the company they're trading. GovGreed's signal engine captures this through the bill correlation and contribution pattern layers.
The pattern is what you'd expect if committee knowledge matters:
- Members of the Armed Services Committee who trade defense stocks score higher on the bill correlation layer than members who trade the same stocks without committee overlap.
- Members of the Financial Services Committee trading bank stocks before regulatory announcements show elevated bill correlation scores.
- Members of the Energy and Commerce Committee trading energy and healthcare stocks show significantly higher sector alignment in GovGreed's lobbying pattern layer.
GovGreed tracks bill-trade correlations — the timing relationship between when a politician trades and when related legislation moves through their committee. A high bill correlation score means the trade landed inside a window of related legislative activity.
all fire on the same trade
behind the trade
This doesn't prove insider trading — GovGreed is a data platform, not a prosecutor. But it does show that the information environment inside congressional committees overlaps with what members trade. The signal engine surfaces these patterns so users can evaluate them.
Top Performers (Bipartisan)
Active trading is bipartisan. Both parties have members who rank highly on GovGreed's signal scores. The table below shows traders ranked by buy win rate (percentage of purchases that beat the S&P 500 over the following 30 days), loaded live from GovGreed's database.
Source: per-politician trade-return aggregates from GovGreed's live database. Win rate = percentage of stock purchases that beat S&P 500 over 30 days. Minimum 20 buy trades required for inclusion. Updated daily. Raw per-member figures on small samples; not a forecast.
Does Being Rich Make You a Better Trader?
You'd assume the wealthiest members — the ones with hundreds of millions in declared assets — would be the sharpest traders. We matched each member's declared net worth (from their Personal Financial Disclosure) against their trading record so you can compare the two.
First, the very richest barely trade at all. Senator Jim Justice (R-WV, ~$1.3 billion) and Rick Scott (R-FL, ~$480M) have almost no active trading record — their wealth sits in operating companies and blind trusts, not a brokerage account they're churning. Among members who do trade actively, the table below loads their record live from GovGreed's database.
| # | Member | Declared net worth | Trades | Buy win rate | Trader tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loading live data… | |||||
Source: declared net worth from Personal Financial Disclosures (most recent parsed filing, assets−liabilities midpoint); buy win rate = share of purchases beating the S&P 500 over 30 days, minimum 25 buys. Large-portfolio members often trade through managed accounts and blind trusts, which dampens any single-name “skill” signal. Loaded live from GovGreed's database.
The Disclosure Delay Problem
The elephant in the room for anyone trying to copy congressional trades: the disclosure gap. Under the STOCK Act, members of Congress have 45 days to disclose a trade. The actual average delay is 50 days (median 28), and 12,766 deduplicated trades (12.8%) were filed after the 45-day deadline.
This creates a structural information asymmetry. By the time the public learns that a senator bought $500,000 of a defense contractor, the stock may have already moved. Any return measured from the trade date describes what the politician saw — not what a copy-trader would see from disclosure date forward.
That said, GovGreed's signal engine partially addresses this by scoring trades at the time of disclosure and using freshness labels (FRESH, NEW, RECENT, AGING, STALE) to indicate how much time has passed since the trade was executed. A high score on a fresh disclosure is the most timely thing the record can show you.
How GovGreed's Signal Engine Works
GovGreed's signal scoring isn't a single model — it's an intelligence fusion engine that combines independent data sources into a composite score. Each input contributes a weighted percentage to the master score, and convergence multipliers amplify trades where multiple inputs agree:
- 20% Politician Quality — Historical trading track record. Win rates, trading styles, options usage, portfolio concentration. 247 politicians scored.
- 20% Herd Signals — 3+ politicians converging on the same stock within a detection window. Currently tracking 31 active herd signals. Multiple members buying the same stock is the clearest convergence pattern.
- 16% Bill Correlation — Timing analysis between trades and legislative activity across every scored trade. Detects trades that occur suspiciously close to favorable committee activity.
- 12% Technical Context — RSI, SMA crossovers, volume surge analysis. Confirms whether the stock's technical picture supports the politician's trade direction.
- 12% Sector Momentum — Congressional buy/sell ratio by sector, combined with sector price momentum. Identifies sectors where insider buying is concentrated.
- 10% Campaign Contributions — 565 contribution patterns mapping campaign donations to subsequent trades in the donor's industry. Follow the money.
- 10% Lobbying Alignment — 2,101 lobbying patterns connecting lobbyist activity to politician trading in the same tickers. Detects influence-to-trade pipelines.
The master score is computed as a weighted sum of all 7 layers, then multiplied by a convergence factor: 1.3x for 3 converging signals, 1.5x for 4, and 2.0x for 5 or more. This multiplicative design means that a trade must light up multiple independent indicators to reach A+ or S tier. A single hot signal alone isn't enough.
The engine runs on 2,790 scored signals across 61 politicians. Only trades with an amount midpoint of $50,000 or more qualify, because small-dollar trades don't carry enough conviction to be statistically meaningful as insider signals.